Home » Blog » Conducting an Effective Investigation with a Reluctant Witness

Vigilant Blog

News, trends and analysis in employment law, HR, safety & workers' comp

Dec 6, 2012

Conducting an Effective Investigation with a Reluctant Witness

A: A successful investigation hinges on making the employee feel safe, comfortable, and important. Interview beyond just direct witnesses so no one feels targeted, and let them know you are not conducting a witch hunt. Most employees don’t realize that harassment investigations are intended to improve their work environment. It is also important to emphasize that witnesses are protected by the company.

Start with broad questions that require more than a “yes” or “no” response (ex: “Describe how your crew works together”), and then move to specifics. Most importantly, follow up with your witnesses and be prepared to back up your assertions to protect employees from retaliation. A culture of protecting employees and their work environment builds trust and makes them willing to share crucial information. If you want more examples of investigation interview questions that work, call your Vigilant staff representative.

Q: I’m trying to do an investigation of alleged harassment, but key witnesses clam up because they don’t want to stir the waters or anger the alleged harasser. How do I get them to talk?

This website presents general information in nontechnical language. This information is not legal advice. Before applying this information to a specific management decision, consult legal counsel.
divider--carrot
About the Author

Jodi Slavik

Employment Attorney & Strategic Services Director Vigilant Law Group
  • Washington State University, B.A. in Political Science
  • Seattle University, J.D.
  • Attorney licensed in Washington
  • Accomplished speaker
  • Lover of all things fun and funny

Is My Company Eligible?

If you are a manufacturing or agriculture employer in Washington and committed to keeping your employees safe and working, you may be eligible for Vigilant's workers' compensation Retro or claims management programs. To see if you qualify fill out our release form now, or contact us.

Don’t Navigate Employment Issues On Your Own

Learn how Vigilant membership can help with your complex employment situations.
Scroll to Top